Chevrolet Silverado 2500HD best and worst years
Each year is compared with the typical (middle) complaint count of the heavy-duty trucks we cover from the same model year, using owner complaints filed with NHTSA. Comparing within a year is fairer than one overall ranking, because older trucks have had more time to collect complaints. Complaint counts show what owners reported, not how reliable a truck is. See what these numbers can't tell you.
Fewest reported complaints for their age
- 201753 complaints vs. 182 typical
- 201853 complaints vs. 127 typical
- 201440 complaints vs. 69 typical
⚠ Diesel onlyThe Duramax LML diesel's CP4.2 high-pressure fuel pump can fail and take the whole fuel system with it, an expensive repair.
- 201973 complaints vs. 104 typical
Some years have a well-known costly problem with one engine. Trucks with other engines aren't affected, but check which engine the truck you're looking at has.
Most reported complaints for their age
- 2007204 complaints vs. 98 typical
- 2011104 complaints vs. 56 typical
⚠ Diesel onlyThe Duramax LML diesel's CP4.2 high-pressure fuel pump can fail and take the whole fuel system with it, an expensive repair.
Every year
| Year | Complaints | Typical that year | Compared |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2007 | 204 | 98 | More than typical |
| 2009 | 61 | 54 | About typical |
| 2011⚠ Known problem: The Duramax LML diesel's CP4.2 high-pressure fuel pump can fail and take the whole fuel system with it, an expensive repair. | 104 | 56 | More than typical |
| 2013⚠ Known problem: The Duramax LML diesel's CP4.2 high-pressure fuel pump can fail and take the whole fuel system with it, an expensive repair. | 51 | 68 | About typical |
| 2014⚠ Known problem: The Duramax LML diesel's CP4.2 high-pressure fuel pump can fail and take the whole fuel system with it, an expensive repair. | 40 | 69 | Fewer than typical |
| 2015⚠ Known problem: The Duramax LML diesel's CP4.2 high-pressure fuel pump can fail and take the whole fuel system with it, an expensive repair. | 176 | 156 | About typical |
| 2016⚠ Known problem: The Duramax LML diesel's CP4.2 high-pressure fuel pump can fail and take the whole fuel system with it, an expensive repair. | 123 | 128 | About typical |
| 2017 | 53 | 182 | Fewer than typical |
| 2018 | 53 | 127 | Fewer than typical |
| 2019 | 73 | 104 | Fewer than typical |
| 2020 | 108 | 112 | About typical |
| 2021 | 87 | 74 | About typical |
| 2022 | 95 | 102 | About typical |
Years not listed are too new to compare fairly, have too few trucks to compare against, or NHTSA lumps them in with other trucks. ⚠ marks years with a well-known costly problem that complaint counts alone don't show.
What each generation is known for
- 2007–20106.6L Duramax LMM diesel and 6.0L V8 gas
Airbag recalls top the complaints; cracked dashes are common and owners on a diesel forum report idler and pitman arm wear; Duramax LMM owners mostly report DPF, EGR and cooler line repairs.
- 2011–20146.6L Duramax LML diesel and 6.0L V8 gas
The Duramax LML's high-pressure fuel pump is the costliest risk; DEF and NOx sensor repairs and airbag recalls are common.
- 2015–20196.6L Duramax diesel (LML 2015–2016, L5P 2017–2019) and 6.0L V8 gas
2015–2016 diesels carry the fuel pump risk; the 2017+ L5P has far fewer fuel pump complaints; trailer brake warnings are common.
- 2020–20266.6L Duramax L5P diesel and 6.6L V8 gas
The 10-speed transmission is the most reported problem, with a valve body recall on 2020–2022 diesels; trailer brake warnings are common.
What these numbers can't tell you
Complaint counts aren't reliability scores, and we don't turn them into one. Keep these limits in mind:
- How many were sold. We don't have reliable sales numbers for every truck and year, so counts aren't adjusted for them. Best-selling trucks collect more complaints simply because more are on the road.
- Engines are mixed together. NHTSA files gas and diesel trucks under the same name, so one troubled engine can be hidden by a larger number of trouble-free ones, or the other way round.
- Not every problem gets reported. Owners mostly report safety problems. Costly failures that aren't a safety risk are often never reported to NHTSA. That's why ⚠ marks years with a well-known costly problem.
- One issue can drive a year. A widely publicized problem or a recall can bring a wave of complaints for a single year.
- New trucks look better. Recent years haven't had time to collect complaints, so we only compare a year once the typical truck that year has at least 50.
The condition and history of the specific truck you're looking at matter more than its year. Always get a pre-purchase inspection and bring our inspection checklist.