GMC Sierra 3500HD best and worst years
Each year is compared with the typical (middle) complaint count of the heavy-duty trucks we cover from the same model year, using owner complaints filed with NHTSA. Comparing within a year is fairer than one overall ranking, because older trucks have had more time to collect complaints. Complaint counts show what owners reported, not how reliable a truck is. See what these numbers can't tell you.
Fewest reported complaints for their age
- 201713 complaints vs. 182 typical
- 20095 complaints vs. 54 typical
- 20147 complaints vs. 69 typical
⚠ Diesel onlyThe Duramax LML diesel's CP4.2 high-pressure fuel pump can fail and take the whole fuel system with it, an expensive repair.
- 201814 complaints vs. 127 typical
- 201913 complaints vs. 104 typical
Some years have a well-known costly problem with one engine. Trucks with other engines aren't affected, but check which engine the truck you're looking at has.
Most reported complaints for their age
No year has clearly more complaints than typical for its age. See every year below.
Every year
| Year | Complaints | Typical that year | Compared |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2007 | 16 | 98 | Fewer than typical |
| 2009 | 5 | 54 | Fewer than typical |
| 2011⚠ Known problem: The Duramax LML diesel's CP4.2 high-pressure fuel pump can fail and take the whole fuel system with it, an expensive repair. | 20 | 56 | Fewer than typical |
| 2013⚠ Known problem: The Duramax LML diesel's CP4.2 high-pressure fuel pump can fail and take the whole fuel system with it, an expensive repair. | 14 | 68 | Fewer than typical |
| 2014⚠ Known problem: The Duramax LML diesel's CP4.2 high-pressure fuel pump can fail and take the whole fuel system with it, an expensive repair. | 7 | 69 | Fewer than typical |
| 2015⚠ Known problem: The Duramax LML diesel's CP4.2 high-pressure fuel pump can fail and take the whole fuel system with it, an expensive repair. | 31 | 156 | Fewer than typical |
| 2016⚠ Known problem: The Duramax LML diesel's CP4.2 high-pressure fuel pump can fail and take the whole fuel system with it, an expensive repair. | 19 | 128 | Fewer than typical |
| 2017 | 13 | 182 | Fewer than typical |
| 2018 | 14 | 127 | Fewer than typical |
| 2019 | 13 | 104 | Fewer than typical |
| 2020 | 45 | 112 | Fewer than typical |
| 2021 | 20 | 74 | Fewer than typical |
| 2022 | 31 | 102 | Fewer than typical |
Years not listed are too new to compare fairly, have too few trucks to compare against, or NHTSA lumps them in with other trucks. ⚠ marks years with a well-known costly problem that complaint counts alone don't show.
What each generation is known for
- 2007–20106.6L Duramax LMM diesel and 6.0L V8 gas
Airbag recalls top the complaints; cracked dashes are common and owners on a diesel forum report idler and pitman arm wear; Duramax LMM owners mostly report DPF, EGR and cooler line repairs.
- 2011–20146.6L Duramax LML diesel and 6.0L V8 gas
The Duramax LML's high-pressure fuel pump is the costliest risk; DEF and NOx sensor repairs and airbag recalls are common.
- 2015–20196.6L Duramax diesel (LML 2015–2016, L5P 2017–2019) and 6.0L V8 gas
2015–2016 diesels carry the fuel pump risk; the 2017+ L5P has far fewer fuel pump complaints; trailer brake warnings are common.
- 2020–20266.6L Duramax L5P diesel and 6.6L V8 gas
The 10-speed transmission is the most reported problem, with a valve body recall on 2020–2022 diesels; trailer brake warnings are common.
What these numbers can't tell you
Complaint counts aren't reliability scores, and we don't turn them into one. Keep these limits in mind:
- How many were sold. We don't have reliable sales numbers for every truck and year, so counts aren't adjusted for them. Best-selling trucks collect more complaints simply because more are on the road.
- Engines are mixed together. NHTSA files gas and diesel trucks under the same name, so one troubled engine can be hidden by a larger number of trouble-free ones, or the other way round.
- Not every problem gets reported. Owners mostly report safety problems. Costly failures that aren't a safety risk are often never reported to NHTSA. That's why ⚠ marks years with a well-known costly problem.
- One issue can drive a year. A widely publicized problem or a recall can bring a wave of complaints for a single year.
- New trucks look better. Recent years haven't had time to collect complaints, so we only compare a year once the typical truck that year has at least 50.
The condition and history of the specific truck you're looking at matter more than its year. Always get a pre-purchase inspection and bring our inspection checklist.